RESIDENT SUES PEMBROKE PINES OVER FIRE FEE
Miami Herald Friday , Sep. 21, 2007
Pembroke Pines resident Phil McConaghey filed a lawsuit against City Hall on Thursday alleging the city's fire fee hike is illegal.
McConaghey, a longtime activist, said the city's fire assessment increase from $74.98 to $153.48 per household to fill the fire department's budget is unfair.
He said 24 percent of the fire department calls don't come from property owners or their renters.
''Some are car fires and in the public right of way,'' said McConaghey adding that money to pay for those accidents should come from city taxes, not fees.
But Mayor Frank Ortis dismissed McConaghey's allegations, saying he lacked expertise on the topic.
''I'm going to support our city attorney who is a friend of the court,'' Ortis said. ``While I might respect Phil's opinion, Phil is not an attorney.''
In 2002, McConaghey won a lawsuit that changed the way cities charged for ambulance services. The Florida Supreme Court ruled that it's illegal for cities to charge a flat fee for each piece of property to pay for ambulance services.
--
